Jan. 12th, 2012

philkmills: Phil and guitar (Default)
[personal profile] catsittingstill wrote a post that mentioned gender in filk songs. I replied with a comment based on my impression of what songs I've written and then decided that I'd like to see whether the facts matched my feelings. I'll ramble on about it here. :-)

A survey of the songs in my filk book that I've written and are first-person from the point of view of a 'character' gives:
Gender-neutral: 41
Male: 35
    Male from books or TV: 24
        Male from Tolkien: 11
Female: 3
    Female from books: 1
I'm not sure what all to take from that:
- If I write from a character's pov there's a 52% chance gender will not be explicit.
- If it's a character I created, the odds of it being gender-neutral go to 76%.
- If I create a pov character where gender is specified, there's an 85% chance of male
- If I select a pre-made one that rises to 94%.

- Many of the songs listed under 'male' and taken from books and shows would be gender-neutral if nobody knew the source material.
- Most of the male/female ones could be switched by changing a given name.
- ...which leaves approximately a half-dozen songs where gender and relationships are important to the point of the story.

April 2012

2223 2425262728

Most Popular Tags

Page Summary

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Sep. 24th, 2017 10:11 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios